Senate milk inquiry leaves sour taste

18 Aug, 2017 04:39 PM
Comments
0
 
Karinjeet Singh-Mahil, who was among producers who were called to give evidence to the Senate inquiry, was scathing about the final report.
Having waited for so long and having cost taxpayers so much money, it was a remarkably disappointing
Karinjeet Singh-Mahil, who was among producers who were called to give evidence to the Senate inquiry, was scathing about the final report.

A south-west Victorian dairy farmer has described the Senate dairy report as “remarkably disappointing.”

Crossley’s Karinjeet Singh-Mahil, who was among producers who were called to give evidence to the inquiry, was scathing about the report.

The Senate’s Economics References Committee released its report, ‘Australia’s dairy industry: rebuilding trust and a fair market for farmers’ late yesterday.

It was set up after farm gate milk price cuts, in 2015-16.

“Having waited for so long and having cost taxpayers so much money, it was a remarkably disappointing result,” Ms Singh-Mahil said.

“It was very general, uninformed and had a factually incorrect basis for some of of the Senators' decisions.”

She said it appeared Senators still believed Fonterra could not reduce their price, until Murray-Goulburn (MG) did.

“They have that written there and it’s a real shame.”

Ms Singh-Mahil said the previous year Fonterra had stayed 20 cents behind MG, right until the end of the season.

“Why is it they believe the spin from the corporates but still don’t understand our industry?” she said.

Among the committee's recommendations was a focus on the new voluntary code of conduct.

“Any review of the code of conduct for contractual relationships should be undertaken by an independent party that can objectively assess whether the code is working as intended and consider if a mandatory code would be more appropriate,” the report said.

The Senators also suggested the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) look at some of the issues, which were raised by farmers.

They called for ACCC to “specially address the issue of unfair contract terms within the dairy industry and provide guidance as to whether milk supply contracts, in principle, fall under the scope of unfair contract term laws.”

The Senators also cast doubt on a proposed milk dairy price index, which would allow farmers to track world price movements.

Gippsland farmer Marian Macdonald was more supportive of the Senate report.

“I think the Senate committee has done a great job of identifying the problem but what we are missing there are some meaningful solutions,” Ms Macdonald said.

She said the voluntary code and proposed milk price index “don’t seem to satisfy the committee.”

“I think the code needs to be mandated, but that’s not within the power of the people who drafted it, so I am not having a go Australian Dairy Farmers (ADF),” she said.

Ms Macdonald said there needed to be penalties for breaching the code.

“One of the things they could have done is look at what other countries have done to safeguard their dairyfarmers in similar situations,” Ms Macdonald said.

She said risk management tools were employed in New Zealand, something the Australian industry had not adopted or openly considered.

“It would have been nice to have investigated those options,” she said.

Ms Macdonald also questioned why the Senators had asked processors to be conservative about opening milk prices to reduce the risk of stepdowns.

“Why should farmers bear all the risk, why is that an expectation? We need to start challenging conventional thinking,” she said.

But she said she felt the inquiry was very helpful but still “a mixed bag”.

“It has peeled back all the layers and made very public and very clear what problems are. It has made it more difficult for status quo to be reinforced,” she said.

“It also doesn’t say there is light at the end of the tunnel it also doesn’t say here is light at the end of the tunnel, this is what could be done, to stop this happening again.

“It basically refers the big issues to the ACCC and I am not sure the ACCC has the power to fix them.”

She thanked consumers for creating the political heat to move the government to act.

United Dairyfarmers of Victoria (UDV) president Adam Jenkins said he was disappointed at the comments about the code of conduct and the dairy index.

“It’s good to see it finally come out – but I think the industry or the ACCC has already embarked on a lot of the things they have recommended,” Mr Jenkins said.

“There is going to be some duplication with the ACCC inquiry, which has more powers.

“But if it is supporting that process, on behalf of farmers, that’s good.”

He said the UDV’s view was that “you have to start somewhere” on issues like the index.

“It may not be perfect, but as things develop over time and as people get behind them, we can make it work,” Mr Jenkins said.

“Too many people try and stop it right at the start - you are better to have something than nothing.”

He was also sceptical of calls for an independent review of the Dairy Australia and Dairy Services levy.

“They already do a review and a have an independent panel.”

Want to read more stories like this?

Sign up to receive our e-newsletter delivered fresh to your email in-box twice a week.

Click here

Page:
1
StockLand

POST A COMMENT


Screen name *
Email address *
Remember me?
Comment *
 
Effective pasture management is one of the most important aspects of successful dairy production, yet many dairyfarmers are not using pasture measurement equipment.17 Feb 18 Effective pasture management is one of the most important aspects of successful dairy production, yet many...
ALLORA, Qld, dairy farmers Andrew and Chris Mullins, Queensland, have been operating in partnership for the past ten years and have a clear vision on how they produce, plus manage, their forage feeding systems. 
05 Feb 18 ALLORA, Qld, dairy farmers Andrew and Chris Mullins, Queensland, have been operating in partnership for the past ten...
light grey arrow
Just wondering if it is true that you will be discontinuing the Devondale long life cream
light grey arrow
The disconnect here is that Farmers believe they are selling a Value Added Product (and, that is
light grey arrow
Read the building regulations, there has been changes for farm buildings. None of this is
Like a lot of dairyfarmers, Steven and Leanne Wieland's Boonah, Qld, business has grown in the past decade.13 Feb 18 Like a lot of dairyfarmers, Steven and Leanne Wieland's Boonah, Qld, business has grown in the past decade.
A Western Australian dairyfarmer says his simple effluent management system is the most cost-effective and labour efficient for his farm.
06 Feb 18 A Western Australian dairyfarmer says his simple effluent management system is the most cost-effective and labour...
Australian farm chemical manufacturer Nufarm has repaired its balance sheet and is now hunting for acquisition opportunities.25 Sep 16 Australian farm chemical manufacturer Nufarm has repaired its balance sheet and is now hunting for acquisition...
Monopoly market may confront cropping sector under mega-merger proposal.22 Sep 16 Monopoly market may confront cropping sector under mega-merger proposal.