Learning from the dairy crisis

03 Jan, 2019 04:00 AM
Comments
0
 
ANGER: Some farmers have reacted angrily to a $200,000 fine meted out to Murray Goulburn's former CEO Gary Helou.
New questions are being raised over the strength of penalties meted out for misleading suppliers...
ANGER: Some farmers have reacted angrily to a $200,000 fine meted out to Murray Goulburn's former CEO Gary Helou.

OPINION: When Australia’s largest dairy processor and farmer co-operative Murray Goulburn announced in April 2016 that it was slashing the farmgate milk price in an attempt to claw back $183 million it had already paid to suppliers, the dairy industry was plunged into a deep crisis.

Farmers were rightly outraged that the industry became paralysed by events that were seemingly preventable.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) took action against the processor in the Federal Court for making false or misleading representations to farmers that it could maintain its opening milk price of $5.60 a kilogram milk solids and a forecast final milk price of $6.05/kg MS when in fact this was not sustainable.

But while Murray Goulburn admitted to this breach of the Australian Consumer Law, which at the time carried a maximum fine of $1.1 million, the ACCC elected not to pursue a financial penalty because as a farmer co-operative, any penalty would likely end up being paid by the very people who were hurt by the company’s actions in 2016.

Related reading

  • Helou ordered to pay $200,000 penalty
  • MG to settle court case with ACCC
  • MG steps down, Helou resigns
  • How MG shot itself in the foot
  • Instead, the blame was dumped squarely at the feet of former managing director Gary Helou, who copped a $200,000 fine for being “knowingly concerned” in Murray Goulburn’s false or misleading claims about the farmgate milk price.

    He must also pay $50,000 to help cover the ACCC’s legal costs and has been banned for three years from any involvement in the dairy industry.

    This outcome should have brought closure to the farmers whose livelihoods were affected by the milk crisis.

    But instead, new questions are being raised over the strength of penalties meted out for misleading suppliers and the need for greater information sharing in ensuring robust accountability processes.

    Some farmers have reacted angrily to a $200,000 fine, which appears to pale in comparison to the $10 million Mr Helou reportedly pocketed during his tenure at the helm of Murray Goulburn – especially when the co-op’s former unitholders have been ordered to pay the ACCC’s remaining legal costs, also amounting to $200,000.

    Farmers are valid in their anger, considering the impacts of the milk crisis on their own businesses and the whole industry.

    But we must remember that at the time the ACCC intervened, the maximum fine that could be imposed on an individual for this breach of the consumer law was just $220,000.

    This has subsequently been increased to $500,000 under new legislation, but the door is open to discuss whether penalties imposed for breaches of the consumer law and Corporations Act are a sufficient deterrent for executive wrongdoing.

    We must consider how these penalties improve governance processes, provide accountability and maintain the trust between farmers and their processors that is vital for success.

    The Murray Goulburn saga reinforces the need to maintain high standards of corporate governance. Anyone who wants to retain a position on a company’s board of directors must be prepared to be held ultimately accountable.

    The dairy industry’s primary goal in the past three years has been to ensure that another governance catastrophe never happens again.

    Australian Dairy Farmers, as the peak dairy farmer body, has done its best to bring the industry together behind measures that will help repair relationships across the supply chain.

    The Federal Government is now moving closer to implementing a mandatory code of practice for the industry.

    There has been intense community interest for the health and well-being of farmers.

    It is encouraging to know that Australians who aren’t involved in the dairy industry understand the stresses caused by the events of 2016.

    The dairy industry needs closure and we are trying to achieve that outcome.

    The recent judgment against Murray Goulburn’s former management is another step towards repairing trust.

    The loss of the Murray Goulburn co-op – which for nearly 70 years was the cornerstone of the Australian dairy industry – continues to cast a long shadow over the industry.

    We must take seriously the lessons learned from the 2016 milk crisis so that we can genuinely rebuild trust between farmers and processors and repair once strong relationships.

    Page:
    3

    POST A COMMENT


    Screen name *
    Email address *
    Remember me?
    Comment *
     
    Best management practice of ryegrass and managing the residual height throughout dry periods is critical to enhance persistence of pasture. 
26 Dec 18 Best management practice of ryegrass and managing the residual height throughout dry periods is critical to enhance...
    A new definition of 'genetically modified' currently awaiting parliamentary approval could see a swathe of new grasses on the market within three years.
13 Nov 18 A new definition of "genetically modified" currently awaiting parliamentary approval could see a swathe of new...
    light grey arrow
    What I find confusion and strange is that the NEW AUSTRALIAN DAIRY PLAN has not got any form or
    light grey arrow
    I am so looking forward to this milk! I have been waiting a long time for it to be on the
    light grey arrow
    Don't fall for the processors changing their contracts. They can change them back again without
    Spending $2.7million to build a new dairy is part of a rolling upgrade and improvement plan for VAN Dairy Group, located at Cape Grim, Tasmania.29 Dec 18 Spending $2.7million to build a new dairy is part of a rolling upgrade and improvement plan for VAN Dairy Group,...
    Australian Dairyfarmer's Jeanette Severs checked out the range of new and interesting products and services on show at the South Gippsland Dairy Expo in September, while Peter Roach caught up with suppliers at the Elmore Field Days in October.02 Dec 18 Australian Dairyfarmer's Jeanette Severs checked out the range of new and interesting products and services on show...
    Australian farm chemical manufacturer Nufarm has repaired its balance sheet and is now hunting for acquisition opportunities.25 Sep 16 Australian farm chemical manufacturer Nufarm has repaired its balance sheet and is now hunting for acquisition...
    Monopoly market may confront cropping sector under mega-merger proposal.22 Sep 16 Monopoly market may confront cropping sector under mega-merger proposal.