Code essential to stop unfair contracts: Keogh

06 Dec, 2018 02:19 PM
Comments
1
 
Mick Keogh: Contracts have become more and more complicated and more opaque.
The work done on ... contracts confirmed that in the absence of a code, issues would be ongoing.
Mick Keogh: Contracts have become more and more complicated and more opaque.

A dairy industry mandatory code is essential to prevent processors from reinstating unfair terms into their contracts, according to Australian Competition and Consumer Commission deputy chairman Mick Keogh.

Mr Keogh told a Dairy Connect ‘Dairy Needs’ Panel Session in Sydney on Thursday there was nothing at present stopping processors from rewriting terms back into their contracts that the ACCC had this year forced them to remove.

But if a mandatory code was in place, the ACCC could take immediate action and there would be penalties for a breach.

Without the code, the ACCC would need to identify that the contract terms were unfair and then take the processor to court to have them changed.

The work done on identifying unfair contract terms confirmed that in the absence of a code, issues would be ongoing.

Related reading

  • Processors change contract terms
  • WA farmers call for standard contracts
  • NSW producers push for fairer code
  • Mr Keogh also identified the complicated nature of contracts as an ongoing issue, not just for the dairy sector but across a wide range of consumer and business sectors.

    "Contracts have become more and more complicated and more opaque," he said.

    "Getting plain-English, easy-to-understand contracts and one you can compare between different processors is difficult."

    One of the recommendations from the ACCC inquiry into the dairy industry that had not been picked up was to have standard profiles (eg 300-cow seasonal farm) against which contracts between different processors could be compared.

    Cost of code

    Mr Keogh said he struggled to understand the concern being expressed at mandatory code consultations about it creating increased farm costs.

    This had not been the case in the horticultural industry, which had had a mandatory code for six years.

    If the paperwork was already in place, it would simply be a matter of ensuring it complied with the code.

    Mr Keogh also dismissed suggestions raised at code meetings that it be extended to supermarkets.

    The supermarkets and their suppliers (such as the processors) were already subject to the Food and Grocery Code of Conduct, and it would not work to have two codes overlapping, he said.

    The ACCC was not involved in the mandatory code consultations, which were being conducted by the federal government, but it anticipated being asked to comment on a draft of the code early next year.

    Contract changes

    Mr Keogh said it had taken the ACCC a year to work through the contracts of major dairy processors (with some having more than a dozen different standard contracts) and then to negotiate the changes required.

    Discussions were ongoing with Saputo and Bega, "but they are broadly in line with where we wanted them to be".

    The changes had come about as a result of unfair contract legislation introduced in November 2016, which required standard-form contracts between large businesses and small businesses to not contain unbalanced terms.

    The legislation required the ACCC to identify unfair terms that were not essential to the contract.

    Mr Keogh said three main types of breaches were identified in dairy contracts.

    The first was unilateral price variation clauses, particularly in multi-year contracts, that allowed a processor to impose a penalty on someone breaking a contract but also giving the processor the right to change the price offered in the contract.

    Most processors had agreed to a 30-day notice provision of a change in price, allowing the farmer to exit the contract without penalty in that period.

    The second breach was terms giving processors the right to make unilateral variations to conditions other than price.

    Written contracts were often subject to the requirements in the supplier handbook, which could be changed by a processor whenever they wanted.

    These had been deemed unfair and now changed, with a couple of processors still working through the detail on this.

    The third breach was terms requiring unreasonable extended notice of termination - some up to 12 months.

    "We've generally had those changed," Mr Keogh said.

    The exception in Western Australia, where the notice period applied to both the supplier and the processor, so was balanced.

    The other was a reworking of the contract condition that limited the ability of a supplier to lease or sell the farm while they remained a supplier.

    Page:
    3
    Date: Newest first | Oldest first

    READER COMMENTS

    Older I Get
    14/12/2018 2:19:13 PM, on Australian Dairyfarmer

    Don't fall for the processors changing their contracts. They can change them back again without the Mandatory code.

    POST A COMMENT


    Screen name *
    Email address *
    Remember me?
    Comment *
     
    A new definition of 'genetically modified' currently awaiting parliamentary approval could see a swathe of new grasses on the market within three years.
13 Nov 18 A new definition of "genetically modified" currently awaiting parliamentary approval could see a swathe of new...
    A person normally breathes about 25,000 times a day, with the lungs taking in oxygen from the air and delivering it to the bloodstream.02 Nov 18 A person normally breathes about 25,000 times a day, with the lungs taking in oxygen from the air and delivering it...
    light grey arrow
    Don't fall for the processors changing their contracts. They can change them back again without
    light grey arrow
    This is all very nice for specific LIon suppliers but it does absolutely nothig for the wider
    light grey arrow
    This is well-written, covers what's going on well. It highlights how wrong the processors
    Australian Dairyfarmer's Jeanette Severs checked out the range of new and interesting products and services on show at the South Gippsland Dairy Expo in September, while Peter Roach caught up with suppliers at the Elmore Field Days in October.02 Dec 18 Australian Dairyfarmer's Jeanette Severs checked out the range of new and interesting products and services on show...
    The floodplain around Kerang and Swan Hill in north-west Victoria is dotted with depressions and surrounding windblown lunettes.29 Nov 18 The floodplain around Kerang and Swan Hill in north-west Victoria is dotted with depressions and surrounding...
    Australian farm chemical manufacturer Nufarm has repaired its balance sheet and is now hunting for acquisition opportunities.25 Sep 16 Australian farm chemical manufacturer Nufarm has repaired its balance sheet and is now hunting for acquisition...
    Monopoly market may confront cropping sector under mega-merger proposal.22 Sep 16 Monopoly market may confront cropping sector under mega-merger proposal.